How do I handle overtime pay correctly?
The basic rule is straightforward. Non-exempt employees get 1.5 times their regular rate for every hour worked over 40 in a workweek. Where businesses run into trouble is calculating the regular rate correctly and making sure workers are classified right in the first place.
A workweek is any fixed period of seven consecutive days. You pick when it starts and keep it consistent. You cannot average hours across two weeks to avoid paying overtime. If someone works 50 hours one week and 30 the next, you still owe overtime for that first week.
Regular rate is not always the same as hourly wage. Nondiscretionary bonuses, commissions, and shift differentials often need to be included when calculating the overtime rate. A $100 weekly production bonus changes the math on what 1.5x actually means. This catches a lot of small business owners off guard.
Exempt versus non-exempt classification causes most violations. Putting someone on salary does not automatically make them exempt from overtime. Employees must meet specific duties tests and earn at least $684 per week to qualify as exempt. Calling someone a supervisor does not count if they spend most of their time doing the same work as hourly staff.
Virginia follows federal overtime law, so there are no additional state requirements. But the Department of Labor can audit you based on complaints, and penalties include back wages plus liquidated damages that can double what you owe.
Common mistakes include not paying for work done off the clock like checking email or setting up before a shift, offering comp time instead of overtime pay, and misclassifying workers as independent contractors. For restaurants with tipped employees, forgetting to include tips in the regular rate calculation is another frequent error.
Track time accurately for all non-exempt employees even if you trust people to work their scheduled hours. Documentation protects you if questions come up later. A Richmond bookkeeper can help you set up systems that make this tracking automatic rather than something you have to chase down.
Getting overtime wrong creates liability that compounds quickly. Two years of underpaying an employee means back pay plus an equal amount in damages. Multiply that across several employees and the exposure becomes serious. Payroll services that include compliance review catch these issues before they become expensive problems.
Greater Richmond's Small Business Bookkeeper
The Next Step:
A Short Conversation
Fifteen minutes to tell us what you're dealing with. We'll let you know how we can help and give you a clear price quote.
More Questions
How long does it take to catch up on a year of bookkeeping?
A year of catch-up bookkeeping typically takes one to four weeks of work time, though this varies based on transaction volume, documentation quality, and business complexity. Cash-heavy businesses and those with disorganized records take longer.
Read answerWhat's the best way to track subcontractor payments?
Collect a W-9 before the first payment, set up each sub as a vendor in your accounting software, and code every payment to the job it belongs to. This setup gives you accurate job costs and makes 1099 filing straightforward.
Read answerShould I use accrual accounting for my e-commerce store?
In most cases, yes. Accrual accounting matches revenue with the costs that generated it, which matters when you hold inventory and sell through platforms with delayed payouts. Cash basis works for very small stores but starts creating blind spots as you grow.
Read answerMy Last Bookkeeper Left My Books in Bad Shape. Can You Fix Them?
Yes. Cleaning up after a previous bookkeeper is a significant part of what we do. Misclassified transactions, unreconciled accounts, missing records. We sort it out and get you back to accurate books.
Read answerWhat's the best way to handle cash management in a restaurant?
Start with consistent register banks and count cash at every shift change. Reconcile to your POS daily, deposit frequently, and limit who handles cash to create clear accountability.
Read answerHow do I track tip income and tip-outs for my restaurant?
Track tips daily using your POS system or a written tip log, record all tip-outs to support staff, and run tips through payroll since they're taxable wages. Both credit card and cash tips need documentation.
Read answer
