Should I run payroll myself or use a payroll service?
Running payroll yourself is possible, especially with only one or two employees on straightforward wages. But payroll involves more than printing checks. You’re responsible for calculating withholdings, making tax deposits on time, filing quarterly reports, and producing W-2s at year end. Miss a deadline or calculate something wrong and the penalties add up fast.
The IRS doesn’t care if you’re a small operation figuring things out. Late payroll tax deposits trigger penalties starting at 2% and climbing to 15% depending on how late. Incorrect withholding means you owe the difference plus interest. These aren’t theoretical risks. They happen regularly to small business owners who thought payroll was simpler than it is.
Payroll software sits between doing everything manually and handing it off completely. Services like Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, or ADP Run calculate withholdings, generate pay stubs, and file taxes automatically. You enter hours, approve the run, and the software handles the rest. This works well if you’re comfortable managing the process and can dedicate consistent time to it each pay period. Most Tri-Cities bookkeepers recommend starting here if you want to stay hands-on but reduce the chance of errors.
Full payroll services take it further. Someone else manages the entire process. You approve hours and they handle everything including troubleshooting when something doesn’t look right. This makes sense when you have tipped employees, commission structures, multiple pay rates, or a mix of W-2 employees and 1099 contractors. It also makes sense if you simply don’t want to think about payroll and would rather spend that time running your business.
The cost comparison isn’t just the service fee versus doing it free. Your time has value. If you’re spending three hours per pay period on payroll when you could be doing billable work or serving customers, that’s a real cost. Add the stress of making sure you filed correctly and the potential penalty if you didn’t.
For most small businesses, the decision comes down to volume and complexity. A sole proprietor with one part-time helper on hourly wages can manage with payroll software. A restaurant with fifteen employees, tip reporting, and varied schedules shouldn’t try to handle that alone. The breakpoint is usually somewhere between three and five employees, or whenever you catch yourself dreading payroll day.
Greater Richmond's Small Business Bookkeeper
The Next Step:
A Short Conversation
Fifteen minutes to tell us what you're dealing with. We'll let you know how we can help and give you a clear price quote.
More Questions
How do I know if a project is actually profitable?
Track all direct costs against each job and allocate a share of overhead. Most owners miss their own labor value and fixed expenses, making projects look more profitable than they really are.
Read answerWhat's the best way to categorize expenses in QuickBooks?
Consistency matters more than the specific categories you choose. Use QuickBooks defaults as a starting point, keep things simple, and match categories to tax return line items for easier year-end prep.
Read answerHow do I handle overtime pay correctly?
Non-exempt employees must receive 1.5 times their regular rate for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. The tricky parts are calculating the regular rate correctly and making sure employees are classified properly.
Read answerWhat's the difference between catch-up bookkeeping and cleanup bookkeeping?
Catch-up bookkeeping addresses a time gap when your books stopped being maintained. Cleanup bookkeeping fixes quality issues like miscategorized transactions and accounts that don't reconcile. Many businesses need both.
Read answerHow do I reconcile my accounts in QuickBooks Online?
Reconciliation compares your QuickBooks records to your bank statement. Start with your statement ending date and balance, then match transactions one by one until the difference is zero.
Read answerHow do I handle progress billing in QuickBooks?
Enable progress invoicing in QuickBooks settings, then create invoices from estimates for partial amounts. The feature is straightforward but only works well if your estimates are accurate and you track costs alongside billings.
Read answer
